Thursday, January 15, 2015

Reposted review of Black Widow: A Beautiful Woman, Two Lovers, Two Murders...

In the interest of posting more true crime book reviews, here's one I wrote about Marion Collins' book, Black Widow: A Beautiful Woman, Two Lovers, Two Murders.  I read this book several years ago.  In fact, I was living in Germany the first time when I read it in 2008.

Lynn Turner was a beautiful sociopath who used antifreeze to murder two men.  Her story is also interesting because one of her victims' mothers is a Seventh Day Adventist, a religion I knew little about when I read the book (and I still don't know too much about it).  Lynn Turner died in her Georgia prison cell in August 2010.  An autopsy showed that she overdosed on blood pressure pills.  I was living in Georgia at the time of her death.

Murdering men for fun and fortune... Feb 9, 2008 (Updated Feb 9, 2008)

Review by knotheadusc
Rated a Very Helpful Review


Pros: Interesting story about a woman who almost got away with two murders.

Cons: Really needs editing. Tabloid feel. Photos don't deliver.

The Bottom Line: Murder will out.

Once again, thanks to Amazon.com's effective suggestive selling techniques, I purchased another true crime book from St. Martin's True Crime Library. To be honest, it's rare that I find high quality true crime books published by St. Martin's Press. I'm more often intrigued by the cases St. Martin's writers cover rather than the quality of their writing. I'm afraid Marion Collins' 2007 book, Black Widow: A Beautiful Woman, Two Lovers, Two Murders represents typical fare for St. Martin's True Crime Library, which to me, is beginning to seem comparable to Harlequin Enterprises... a publisher that seems to emphasize quantity over quality.

I bought Black Widow because I was interested in reading about Julia "Lynn" Turner. The beautiful young woman known as Lynn curiously became a widow when her strapping young police officer husband, Glenn, died suddenly of what doctors originally thought was a extremely virulent flu bug. Glenn Turner died in agony, yet his wife was strangely unemotional at his funeral. Afterwards, she came into large sums of cash when a number of life insurance policies paid out.

Recruitment for Hell on Earth

Glenn Turner, who lived in Georgia his whole life and was raised in the Seventh Day Adventist Church, was a popular cop who had many friends and was well loved by his family. His friends and family had warned him about Lynn, a woman who seemed to have an affinity for men in uniform. Lynn Turner was very flashy and had very expensive tastes. When she set her sights on her potential boyfriends, she would launch ruthless campaigns to win them over. She bought them expensive gifts, dressed provocatively, and flattered them incessantly. A lot of people wondered how Lynn, a former sheriff's assistant and 911 operator, was able to afford the gifts she lavished on Glenn when they were dating. Somehow, Lynn Turner convinced Glenn that she was going to inherit a lot of money when her grandmother died. She had him thinking that she was going to make him rich.

The reality of a bad marriage

Glenn and Lynn Turner were married in August 1993. Glenn's youngest brother, Jimmy, as best man, was asked to give a toast at their wedding reception. Jimmy said words that turned out to be very prophetic when he commented, "I feel like I'm more at a funeral than a wedding." The words were shocking and offensive. Everybody laughed except Lynn, who shot her new brother in law a look of pure hatred.

Then, after a disastrous honeymoon, Glenn Turner found out that the generous woman he thought he was marrying was actually a slave driver who expected him to support her extravagant tastes. Determined to make the marriage work, Glenn took on extra jobs, earning more money to pay off Lynn's enormous debts. Meanwhile, while Glenn was working non-stop, Lynn had another man on the side.

Randy Thompson

Randy Thompson, a firefighter, never knew that his girlfriend, Lynn, was married. He only knew that she was pretty and very generous. Lynn Turner presented Randy with $1100 boots and brand new cars. She never let on that she had a husband who was working two or three jobs at a time to help support her adulterous fling.

March 3, 1995

On March 3, 1995, Lynn Turner became a widow when 31 year old Glenn Turner died of a mysterious illness. Glenn's family suspected that something wasn't right when he suddenly passed. An autopsy showed that he had an enlarged heart, but no one had ever known Glenn to have problems with his heart. After his funeral, Lynn Turner went on with life as if nothing ever happened. She neatly cut Glenn's family out of her life as she moved in on Randy Thompson.

History repeats itself

Lynn Turner loved the thrill of the chase. When she was in hot pursuit of a man, she lavished him with gifts and attention. Once she had him in her clutches, she became a different person, as was the case in her relationship with Randy Thompson. Lynn Turner never married Randy, but she did bear two children by him. She used the children to maintain control and to get Randy to buy more life insurance, just in case he should meet an untimely death.

On January 21, 2001, 32 year old Randy Thompson did, in fact, die of a mysterious illness. At the time of his death, he was trying to get his life back on track and repair his relationship with Lynn for the sake of their children. But Lynn Turner had other plans. She concluded that Randy Thompson was worth much more to her dead than alive. An autopsy revealed that like Glenn Turner before him, Randy Thompson had an enlarged heart.

Two families put their heads together

A lot of people were suspicious when Glenn Turner died. Those same people became even more leery when Randy Thompson died under uncannily similar circumstances. Kathy Turner, Glenn's mother, made a phone call to Angie Bollinger, Randy's sister. Angie didn't want to believe that the two deaths were anything but a coincidence. But she did talk about the phone call with her family. Kathy Turner, meanwhile, decided to appeal to Randy's mother, Nita Thompson. It took months, but she finally connected with the woman, who never suspected that Randy's death was the result of foul play. The two mothers compared notes and suddenly, Lynn Turner started to look like an awful lot like a serial killer.

My thoughts

To be honest, I think Black Widow could have been a much better book. The case is certainly interesting enough to warrant writing about. Lynn Turner is a fascinating character who fell into the trap of overconfidence and almost got away with two murders. Unfortunately, like so many books I've read from St. Martin's True Crime Library, this book is rife with editing glitches. There were a couple of passages that didn't add up because it seemed like words were missing. Consider the following passage copied word for word from page 28 in chapter three:

She never knew her birth parents, who were divorced when she was 2 on account of her father's womanizing. When she was 5, she was adopted by Helen Womack, who named her new daughter Julia Lynn. Quickly the Julia was dropped, and she was known simply as Lynn.

Her new parents' marriage turned out to be no more stable than that of her natural kin: the Womacks separated when Lynn was 2, and divorced soon afterward.


I'm guessing that Lynn must have been adopted when she was five months old and not five years old, as the passage seems to suggest. Otherwise, these two explanatory paragraphs don't make sense. This is not the only incidence of confusing wording, although it is probably the most egregious example. For a book that consists of less than 300 pages, it does seem that Black Widow was rushed and consequently, it didn't get adequate attention from an editor.

This book also promises eight pages of "alarming" photographs. While Black Widow does include a photo section, I don't think I'd describe the pictures as "alarming". There's a picture of the Seventh Day Adventist Church where Kathy Turner prays for her son, and a couple of shots of key places and people in the case. There is only one picture of Lynn Turner, and it's not even a particularly revealing photo, as it's a candid snapshot that was taken at a bridal shower.

I did appreciate Collins' commentary on the court case, although she spends a good two thirds of the book building up to it. But this book did have sort of a tabloid feel to it. I didn't find it nearly as satisfying as reading a book by an author like Ann Rule or Kathryn Casey, two writers who really dig into their cases and present much more detail than Collins did. I tend to learn things when I read books by Ann Rule and Kathryn Casey. I didn't learn so much reading Black Widow.

That said, I don't think Black Widow is a total bust. I will recommend it to those who like true crime and don't mind editing snafus. It's a short book, so the editing problems won't be troublesome for too long. But I do think this book could have been much better. I hope a better writer and publisher take a stab at publishing this story.


Recommend this product? Yes

2 comments:

  1. A higher percentage of doctors are Seventh-Day Adventists than would be expected based on their representation in the total population figures, presumably because they have a medical school, which most other fringe religions don't have. I've read up on their church, its start, and their beliefs. I think it's all weirder than hell. They're right up there with the Mormons and JWs except that they avoid so much scrutiny by being a bit less evangelical. many are very good people, I;m sure, but their religion is bizarre in my opinion.

    ReplyDelete
  2. I remember in the 80s, hearing about a Baby Fae who was at Loma Linda getting a baboon heart.

    ReplyDelete

Comments on older posts will be moderated until further notice.